Should have: looking back at past choices
Use should have to look back at past choices: how the pattern is built, regret and shouldn't have, softening criticism, the expectation meaning, should have versus must have, a short dialogue and an exercise with answers.
Prepared by GrammarDots, · How we prepare posts
Guide: Grammar. Main post: English grammar topics by level: an A1 to B2 list
Should have + past participle describes something that would have been the right thing to do but didn't happen: “I should have left earlier.” The negative, shouldn't have, describes something that did happen and that you now wish hadn't. Below: the pattern, regret and criticism, the expectation meaning, should have versus must have, a dialogue and an exercise.
Building the sentence
| Sentence type | Pattern | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Positive | subject + should have + past participle | I should have called you. |
| Negative | subject + shouldn't have + past participle | You shouldn't have paid. |
| Question | Should + subject + have + past participle? | Should we have booked? |
| In speech | should've, shouldn't've | We should've asked. |
Should have doesn't change with the subject: “she should have”, “they should have”. It's always followed by a past participle. For regular verbs, that's the -ed form (checked, booked); irregular verbs have to be learnt: go, went, gone; take, took, taken; write, wrote, written. So it's “should have gone”, not “should have went”, and “should have written”, not “should have wrote”.
In speech, have is rarely pronounced in full; “should've” sounds much like “shoulda”. That's why you'll see the mistake “should of”; write should've or should have. The question form is rarer, mostly for doubting your own decision: “Should I have told her?”
Play this topicMultiple ChoiceLevel B1Regret: looking back at your own choices
The most common use is looking at your own past decision and saying what would have been better. “I should have saved the file” tells the listener two things at once: you didn't save it, and that was a mistake.
Ending a regret with a plan moves the conversation forward: “I should have started revising sooner. Next time, I'll make a timetable in the first week.” Say what would have been better with should have, then add what you'll do next time with will.
Shouldn't have: it happened, and it was a mistake
The negative works the other way round: something did happen, and it wasn't a good idea. “I shouldn't have eaten so much cake”: you ate it, and now you regret it. “We shouldn't have taken the motorway; the traffic was terrible”: you took it, and it was the wrong choice. In short, the positive sentence describes something that didn't happen, and the negative describes something that did.
This matters when you translate. “I shouldn't have said that” and “I didn't say that” are very different: the first admits you said it and regrets it, while the second denies it. There's also a polite set phrase: when someone brings you a present, you say “Oh, you shouldn't have!” It isn't criticism; it's a warm thank-you, close to the Turkish “Hiç zahmet etmeseydin.”
Criticism, and how to soften it
With you as the subject, the sentence becomes criticism: “You should have told me.” “You shouldn't have shouted at him.” Both are correct but can sound harsh. To soften them, include yourself or ask a question.
Direct: “You should have checked the figures.” Softer: “We should probably have checked the figures together.” As a question: “Do you think we should have checked the figures first?” Probably and maybe leave room for doubt, and we shares the responsibility.
Expectation: it was due to happen by now
Sometimes should have expresses expectation rather than regret: “The parcel should have arrived by now.” The plan was for it to be here. This use often comes with by now, by this time or already: “Ece should have finished work already. Let's call her.”
It's the past version of should meaning “this is what we expect”. “She should be home at six” becomes, once six o'clock has passed, “She should have got home by now.” Nobody is blamed; you're comparing the plan with reality.
Should have or must have?
For Turkish speakers, the most confusing contrast is between “-malıydı” and “-mış olmalı”. “Gelmeliydi” is should have come: it was necessary or expected. “Gelmiş olmalı” is must have come: a confident guess based on evidence. Compare “The lights are on. She must have come home.” with “She should have come home an hour ago.”
In short, should have describes what was right or expected, and must have describes a conclusion you've drawn. For less certain guesses about the past, use might have or could have: “He might have missed the bus.” To refresh should for advice about now and the future, see the guide to can, could and should.
A short conversation after a missed train
Ali: We've missed it. The next one isn't for an hour. Sue: I knew it. We should've left the café earlier. Ali: You're right. And I shouldn't have ordered that second coffee. Sue: Never mind. The board said it was delayed, though. It shouldn't have gone yet. Ali: Maybe they changed it. We should've checked the app before we walked over. Sue: Next time we'll check it before we leave.
In this conversation, should've and shouldn't have express regret: they left the café late, and the second coffee wasn't a good idea. “It shouldn't have gone yet” is an expectation: according to the board, the train wasn't due to leave. The last line turns regret into a plan.
Look back and rewrite
Make a sentence with should have or shouldn't have for each situation, using the verb in brackets. 1. You didn't charge your phone, and it died on the way. (charge) 2. You watched a series until midnight, and this morning you're exhausted. (stay up) 3. Your friend was late because he went to the wrong address; tell him gently. (check) 4. The meeting was due to start ten minutes ago, but the room is empty. (start) 5. You didn't take your coat, and you got cold. (take)
Possible answers: 1. I should have charged my phone. 2. I shouldn't have stayed up so late. 3. Maybe you should have checked the address. (maybe softens it) 4. The meeting should have started by now. (expectation, no blame) 5. I should have taken my coat. (take, took, taken) The activity at the end of this post practises the same kind of thinking with conditionals about the past.
Frequently asked questions
Do should and should have refer to the same time?
No. “You should rest” is advice about now or the near future. “You should have rested” judges a past choice; the moment for resting has already gone.
Is should have connected to the third conditional?
Yes, they often appear together: “I should have left earlier. If I had left earlier, I wouldn't have missed the train.” Should have says what would have been right; the third conditional says how the result would have changed. For the full set of conditionals, see the guide to if sentences.
Related posts
- Although, despite and in spite of: what's the difference?All three express contrast, but different structures follow them: a full clause after although, and a noun or an -ing form after despite and in spite of. Also even though, the fact that, commas, mistakes that come from Turkish, a sample email and an exercise with answers.
- Reported speech: passing on what people saidThe difference between say and tell, when the tense moves back and when it stays, updating pronouns and time words, reporting questions with if and whether, requests and instructions, a short workplace conversation and an exercise with answers.
- Past perfect: looking further back in timeUse had and a past participle to put two past events in order: the forms, how it works with when, after, before and by the time, a short flashback in a story, where Turkish -mıştı can mislead you, and an exercise with answers.