Second language acquisition theories explained for teachers (Krashen, Long, Swain, Schmidt)
Krashen's comprehensible input and acquisition–learning distinction, Long's interaction, Swain's output and Schmidt's noticing hypotheses, and sociocultural theory: what each says, what has been questioned, and what it means in class, with the ten principles Rod Ellis drew from the research.
Prepared by GrammarDots, · Updated · How we prepare posts
Guide: For teachers. Main post: Classroom English games and digital activities for teachers
Second language acquisition (SLA) theories try to explain how people learn a language after their first one. Five views shaped the classroom most: Krashen's comprehensible input, Long's interaction, Swain's output, Schmidt's noticing and sociocultural theory. None explains learning on its own; Rod Ellis's review for the New Zealand Ministry of Education turns the research into ten principles for teachers.
| Theory | Core idea | What it means in class |
|---|---|---|
| Krashen: comprehensible input | We acquire language when we understand input a little beyond our level. | Plenty of reading and listening made clear by context and pictures |
| Long: interaction | Negotiating meaning makes input comprehensible and brings feedback. | Information-gap tasks |
| Swain: output | Speaking and writing push learners to attend to grammar. | Telling a story from start to finish |
| Schmidt: noticing | There is no learning without conscious attention to specific forms. | Corrective feedback that shows the correct form |
| Sociocultural theory | Learning happens through supportive talk with others. | Writing together; the teacher helps as much as needed, then steps back |
Krashen: acquisition, learning and comprehensible input
In Principles and Practice in Second Language Acquisition, published in 1982, Stephen Krashen set out five hypotheses. The core idea is that we develop a language in two separate ways: “acquiring” it without noticing, while communicating, and “learning” its rules consciously. For Krashen, fluent speech is started by the acquired system; consciously learned rules work only as a monitor, or editor.
| Hypothesis | What it says | What it means in class |
|---|---|---|
| Acquisition–learning distinction | Language develops in two separate ways: unconscious acquisition and conscious learning. | Explaining rules does not bring fluency on its own; meaningful use is needed. |
| Natural order | Grammatical structures are acquired in a predictable order. | A structure not used correctly straight away does not mean teaching has failed. |
| Monitor | Conscious rules are used only with enough time, attention on form, and knowledge of the rule. | Rules help in written work; in fast speech they often do not. |
| Input | Acquisition happens when we understand language a little beyond our level (i + 1). | Choose texts and talk learners can understand with help from context and pictures. |
| Affective filter | With high anxiety and low confidence or motivation, input does not turn into acquisition. | Build a safe class where fear of mistakes is lower. |
Krashen's most debated view is that grammar teaching does not add to acquired (implicit) knowledge. Ellis's review shows that researchers disagree here: in some theories implicit knowledge grows out of explicit knowledge made automatic through practice; in others it develops naturally out of meaning-focused communication, perhaps helped by some attention to form. In Ellis's account, what they agree on is that learners need chances to take part in communicative activity either way.
Long: the interaction hypothesis
As Ellis reports it, Michael Long's interaction hypothesis says that acquisition is helped most when a communication problem arises and learners work to make meaning clear to each other (negotiation of meaning). The clarification requests and reformulations that follow make input comprehensible, provide corrective feedback and push learners to repair their own sentences. In the studies Ellis summarises, tasks that are two-way, that split the information between learners and that lead to one right outcome produced more negotiation of meaning. In class this means information-gap tasks in which two learners hold different information: one knows the bus times, the other the meeting time, and together they find a time that works.
Swain: the output hypothesis
Merrill Swain's output hypothesis argues that understanding is not enough: learners also need to produce the language by speaking and writing. Ellis's review notes that, contrary to Krashen's view that acquisition depends entirely on comprehensible input, most researchers now accept that output plays a part too. According to the review, producing language forces learners to attend to grammar, lets them test their guesses about the language through the feedback their errors receive, and makes what they know automatic. What Swain calls “pushed output” is production in which learners stretch themselves to express a message clearly and fully: telling a story from start to finish or defending a view with reasons, rather than short-answer exercises.
Schmidt: the noticing hypothesis
Richard Schmidt's noticing hypothesis holds, as Ellis reports it, that there is no learning without conscious attention to language forms, and that attention has to go to specific forms rather than to language in general. The hypothesis also stresses learners seeing the gap between what they said and the correct form (noticing the gap). This is one explanation of why corrective feedback can work: when the teacher shows the correct form, learners may notice a form they would otherwise miss.
Sociocultural theory: learning is done together
Most of the views above study language as processes of input and output. Sociocultural theory sees learning instead as socially constructed: learners learn through the supportive talk that arises when they communicate with others, for example step-by-step help from the teacher or a classmate (scaffolding). Within this frame, Ellis's review covers research on the collaborative talk in which learners support each other during a task. In class this means activities where learners write a text or solve a task together, and the teacher helps as much as needed and then steps back.
From theory to class: Ellis's ten principles
At the end of his review, Ellis states the generalisations from the research as ten principles and presents them not as fixed rules but as a broad basis for evidence-based practice. The principles are shortened below; the examples are this post's own.
| Principle (shortened) | A classroom example |
|---|---|
| 1. Develop both ready-made expressions and rule-based knowledge | Teaching “Could you…?” as a chunk, then moving to how questions are formed |
| 2. Focus mainly on meaning | Really discussing a holiday plan |
| 3. Also focus on form | A short note on “going to” during the planning |
| 4. Aim mainly at implicit knowledge without neglecting explicit knowledge | Plenty of use, with a brief rule explanation when needed |
| 5. Take the learner's “built-in syllabus” into account | Not expecting a structure to be perfect before the learner is ready |
| 6. Provide extensive input | Using a lot of English in class; graded readers at the right level |
| 7. Provide opportunities for output | Telling a story from start to finish |
| 8. Interaction is central | Information-gap activities |
| 9. Take individual differences into account | Different levels of support for the same task |
| 10. Assess free as well as controlled production | A short speaking task alongside gap-fills |
Most of these principles rely on a class that is tolerant of mistakes and encourages speaking. To share with learners, reducing the fear of speaking describes steps that lower anxiety from the learner's point of view. Ways to get plenty of input outside class through series and films are in learning English with series and films.
Sources: Krashen, S. D. (1982), Principles and Practice in Second Language Acquisition (full text on the author's website), chapter II; Ellis, R. (2005), Instructed Second Language Acquisition: A Literature Review, New Zealand Ministry of Education (full text). The views of Long, Swain and Schmidt are given as reported in Ellis's review. All read on 9 October 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Is Krashen's theory still accepted today?
The importance of comprehensible input is widely accepted, but his views that grammar teaching does not add to implicit knowledge and that acquisition depends only on input are debated. According to Ellis's review, most researchers now accept that output and attention to form also play a part.
Which theory is right?
None on its own. The theories look at different sides of language learning: input, interaction, production, attention and social support. That is why Ellis's ten principles draw on more than one of them.
Should grammar be taught?
According to Ellis's principles, the focus should be mainly on meaning, but form also needs attention and explicit knowledge should not be neglected. In short, the question is not “should I teach it?” but “when, and how much?”.
Related posts
- Although, despite and in spite of: what's the difference?All three express contrast, but different structures follow them: a full clause after although, and a noun or an -ing form after despite and in spite of. Also even though, the fact that, commas, mistakes that come from Turkish, a sample email and an exercise with answers.
- Should have: looking back at past choicesUse should have to look back at past choices: how the pattern is built, regret and shouldn't have, softening criticism, the expectation meaning, should have versus must have, a short dialogue and an exercise with answers.
- Reported speech: passing on what people saidThe difference between say and tell, when the tense moves back and when it stays, updating pronouns and time words, reporting questions with if and whether, requests and instructions, a short workplace conversation and an exercise with answers.